One of the problems with the future of publishing debates (and you know there are so many of those) is that there are a variety of publishers and not every scenario is going to equally fit each and every publisher.

A topic I don’t see mentioned too often is the difference between reading and book buying habits:

Not everyone who reads a lot also buys a lot of books.

The people who buy books represent a smaller segment than people who read. People who borrow mostly from the library or mostly frequent used bookstores are likely people who don’t buy a lot of new books anyway.

Maybe I’m wrong, but publishers are probably more concerned about people who buy books, which is a smaller segment than people who read. Invariably, someone will say that publishers have to decide which industry they are in - the book business or the information business. Good question. But the answer may not be the same for every publisher.

It’s also the same question that libraries face and later I’ll examine how libraries dealt with that.